Owner Resources

Workers’ Comp Insurance Options for Concrete Businesses

A truck-mounted concrete boom pump parked on a gravel yard with aggregate stockpiles behind — workers’ comp insurance options for concrete businesses

A concrete business can structure workers’ comp in several ways: a standard fixed-cost policy, the same policy billed on reported payroll, coverage through a professional employer organization, a loss-sensitive plan, a state fund where one is offered, or self-insurance for an employer whose finances and records support it. Which one fits depends on payroll size, loss history, cash flow and the states where crews work.

This post is for concrete contractors, pumpers and ready-mix producers deciding how their workers’ comp should be built. The companion question of where the policy comes from, a private carrier, a state fund or the assigned-risk plan, is covered in where to get workers’ comp for concrete employees. This post is about the structure once you know the source.

The standard policy, and how it is billed

Most concrete businesses carry a standard policy, often called guaranteed cost. Premium is set from your payroll in each class, the carrier’s rates and your experience mod, and it does not change during the term because of the claims you have. At the end of the term the carrier audits actual payroll and adjusts the premium up or down.

That structure is predictable, but it comes with a deposit at the start and an audit at the end. For a concrete contractor whose payroll grows quickly in a busy season, the audit can bring a large bill. The experience mod post explains the multiplier that drives the price.

Pay-as-you-go billing keeps the same policy and changes how it is paid. Premium is calculated from the payroll you actually run each period, often through your payroll provider, so the deposit is smaller and premium follows the crew as it grows or shrinks. The audit still happens, but the adjustment is usually smaller. For a seasonal flatwork or foundation crew, this is often the simplest improvement available.

Professional employer organizations

A professional employer organization, or PEO, becomes a co-employer of your crew for payroll, benefits and workers’ comp, and your employees are generally covered under a policy the PEO arranges. For a small crew this can mean one bill for payroll and coverage and access to a carrier that might not write a small concrete account on its own.

The tradeoffs are real. You give up some control over the policy, the claims handling and the classification of your payroll. General contractors may ask questions about a certificate that names the PEO. If you leave, you may need to rebuild a loss record of your own before carriers price your account on its merits. Ask how the PEO handles certificates, claims and the move back to your own policy before you sign.

Workers’ comp structures from fixed cost to retained risk A diagram for a concrete employer comparing workers’ comp structures. Stacked boxes run from the most predictable cost at the top to the most risk kept by the employer at the bottom: a fixed-cost policy, the same policy with pay-as-you-go billing, coverage through a professional employer organization, loss-sensitive plans such as large-deductible or dividend programs, and self-insurance with state approval. No figures are shown. Most predictable cost Fixed-cost policy Pay-as-you-go billing Professional employer organization Loss-sensitive plans Self-insurance with state approval More of the risk stays with you
Workers’ comp structures for a concrete business, from a fixed-cost policy at the top to self-insurance at the bottom, where the employer keeps the most risk.

Loss-sensitive plans

Larger concrete contractors sometimes move to plans where the cost follows their own losses. In general terms:

  • Large-deductible plans have the employer reimburse the carrier for each claim up to a deductible, in exchange for a lower premium. Carriers usually require collateral, such as a letter of credit.
  • Dividend plans keep a standard policy but may return part of the premium after the term if losses are low. A dividend is generally not promised in advance and depends on the carrier’s decision.
  • Retrospective rating adjusts premium after the term based on the claims that occurred, within agreed bounds.

These plans reward a contractor with a steady safety record and enough payroll for its own losses to be predictable. They also expose the business to a bad year. The guide to reducing workers’ comp costs covers the safety and claims work that makes them viable.

Next step. Send your payroll by type of work, the states where crews work and your loss history through the quote form. We bring it to carriers before a policy binds.

Real-World Scenario: A growing foundation contractor has carried workers’ comp through a PEO since it hired its first crew. The company now has a full safety program and a clean claims record, but general contractors keep asking about certificates that name the PEO, and the owner has little say in how claims are handled. The contractor moves to its own standard policy on pay-as-you-go billing and begins building an experience record in its own name.

State funds and self-insurance

In states that run a fund alongside private carriers, the fund is another source for a standard policy, and in a few states it is the required source. The workers’ compensation coverage page and the where-to-get post above cover those states.

Self-insurance requires state approval, and the bar is high. Georgia’s State Board of Workers’ Compensation requires an employer seeking to self-insure to apply with audited financial statements and, if approved, to post a surety bond or letter of credit (Georgia SBWC). Florida requires proof of financial strength to its Self-Insurers Guaranty Association and authorization from the Department of Financial Services (Fla. Stat. 440.38). Louisiana also lists a group self-insurance fund among the ways an employer can secure coverage (La. R.S. 23:1168). For most concrete businesses, self-insurance is a long-term option, not a starting point.

Choosing the structure

Start from the standard policy and ask what would improve it: billing on actual payroll, a PEO while the crew is small, or a loss-sensitive plan once payroll and safety support it. The concrete construction page shows how workers’ comp fits with the rest of a contractor’s program. To have your options priced, use the quote form.

The bottom line

Most concrete businesses buy a standard fixed-cost workers’ comp policy, often billed on reported payroll to smooth cash flow and audits. Small crews sometimes use a PEO. Larger contractors with steady safety records can look at loss-sensitive plans, and only employers with the financial records a state requires can self-insure. Choose the structure that fits your payroll, losses, cash flow and states.

Frequently asked questions

What are the options for workers’ comp insurance for a concrete company?

The common structures are a standard policy with a fixed rate, the same policy billed on actual payroll each pay period, coverage through a professional employer organization, loss-sensitive plans such as large-deductible or dividend programs, a state fund where one is offered, and self-insurance for employers that qualify. Most small and mid-sized concrete contractors start with a standard policy.

What is pay-as-you-go workers’ comp, and is it good for a concrete contractor?

Pay-as-you-go bills premium from the payroll you actually run each period, usually through your payroll service, instead of a large deposit based on an estimate. It suits concrete work because payroll swings with the season and the backlog. It does not remove the audit, but the audit adjustment is usually smaller because premium has tracked real payroll.

Should a small concrete business use a PEO for workers’ comp?

A PEO can make sense for a small crew that wants payroll, HR and workers’ comp in one place, or that has trouble finding a carrier. The tradeoffs are less control over the policy and claims, possible questions from general contractors about certificates, and work to rebuild your own loss record if you leave. Ask how the PEO handles certificates and claims before signing.

Can a concrete company self-insure workers’ comp?

Only with state approval, and states set a high bar. Georgia’s State Board of Workers’ Compensation, for example, requires an application with audited financial statements and, if approved, a surety bond or letter of credit. Some states also allow group self-insurance funds for employers in the same industry. Self-insurance generally fits only large employers with strong finances and records.

About the author

Nate Jones, CPCU

Nate Jones, CPCU, is the founder of Wexford Insurance and Concrete Guard Insurance, a specialty insurance agency placing concrete contractor coverage in 48 states across a 23-carrier specialty panel. Connect via the Concrete Guard Insurance quote form or call 317-942-0549.

Insure your concrete operation with a CPCU-led agency

Tell us how you work — an install crew, a pump truck, a ready-mix fleet, or all three — and we will market it to carriers that write the class.