Compare concrete contractor insurance quotes line by line on limits, exclusions, endorsements and who is insured, because two quotes at different prices are rarely for the same coverage. Price is the last comparison, made after you know both quotes cover the same work.
This post is for concrete contractors who have two or more quotes in hand, or are about to ask for them. The post on what moves your premium explains why prices differ; this one shows how to read the quotes themselves.
Start by sending the same information
A comparison is only fair if every quote was built on the same facts. Give each agent or carrier the same description of operations, the same payroll and revenue split by type of work, the same subcontractor costs and the same loss history. If one application says flatwork only and another includes foundations and pumping, the prices will differ for that reason alone.
Ask each quote to state the classifications and exposure figures it used. Differences there explain many price gaps before the coverage is even considered.
Limits: check each one
A general liability quote shows several limits, and they do not always move together. Check the per-occurrence limit, the general aggregate, the products-completed operations aggregate and whether the aggregate applies per project. The completed operations aggregate post explains why that limit matters for finished work.
Then check deductibles. A quote may carry a deductible or a self-insured retention on each claim, and the two work differently when a claim comes in. On commercial auto, compare liability limits and the physical damage deductibles unit by unit.
Exclusions: ask for the forms list
The summary page of a quote almost never shows the exclusions. Ask for the schedule of forms and endorsements and read the titles. For a concrete contractor, the ones that change a claim outcome are usually these:
- Residential, tract home or condominium work.
- Earth movement or subsidence.
- Damage to completed work performed by subcontractors.
- Work above a stated height, or particular types of projects.
- Conditions that require certificates and hold-harmless agreements from every subcontractor.
A quote that excludes work you perform leaves that work uninsured at any price. The flatwork general liability post explains the exclusions that matter most on slab work.
Endorsements your contracts require
Pull the insurance section from a recent contract and check each quote against it. General contractors commonly require additional insured status for ongoing and completed operations, primary and noncontributory wording and a waiver of subrogation. The additional insured post explains the endorsements, and the guide to what clients require lists the usual requests.
If a quote does not include an endorsement your contracts demand, you cannot issue a compliant certificate from it. State law also limits how far these clauses reach. Colorado, for example, allows construction contracts to require additional insured coverage only to the extent it covers liability arising from the acts or omissions of the party providing it.
Next step. Send the quotes you have through the quote form with a sample contract. We read the form before it binds.
Real-World Scenario: A foundation contractor receives two general liability quotes, and one is noticeably cheaper. The owner picks the cheaper one. At the first certificate request, the general contractor asks for additional insured coverage on completed operations, and the new policy does not offer it. The contractor pays to add the endorsement mid-term, and the two quotes end up closer in price than they first appeared.
Who is insured and who is writing it
Check the named insured on each quote. Every entity that signs contracts, owns trucks or employs people should be listed. A related company left off the policy has no coverage under it.
Then look at the carrier. A quote may come from an admitted carrier, which files its forms and rates with the state, or from a surplus lines carrier, which has more freedom in both. Surplus lines policies typically add state taxes and fees and are generally not backed by a state guaranty fund. Either type can be appropriate for a concrete contractor, but you should know which one each quote is. Your state insurance department can confirm that a carrier and an agent are licensed; the NAIC directory links to each one.
How the premium is audited
Most general liability and workers’ compensation policies for contractors are priced on estimated payroll or revenue and audited after the term. Compare the estimates each quote used, the rate for each classification and any minimum premium that is kept even if your exposure comes in lower. A low quote built on understated payroll becomes an audit bill later.
Ask how each quote treats subcontractor costs as well. Many carriers charge for payments to subcontractors who cannot show their own insurance, so quotes that handle uninsured subcontractors differently will audit to different final premiums.
Once the terms match, compare the prices. To have your quotes reviewed against your contracts, use the quote form.